052-5927592 17 Tzahal Street, Ness Ziona Sun-Thu 09:00-19:00, Fri 09:00-12:30

Building and extending in a house not registered as a condominium: what the Superintendent held

In a house not yet registered as a condominium, the relationship between the owners is governed mainly by the co-ownership agreement between them. Construction and additions require consent, and where there is a dispute over the scope of that consent, the party claiming that it was limited must prove it. In the case we handled, most of the claim against our client was dismissed.

What happened in the case?

A house comprising six apartments in Binyamina, on a large plot, not yet registered as a condominium. Each side held half of the parcel under a division plan. Our client built and sold apartments in his part. The neighbours claimed that he had departed from the permit and from what had been agreed, caused damage to the beam, the column and the roof, positioned water heaters in a harmful manner and split off a residential unit. Earlier proceedings between the parties had been struck out in 2017 following oral agreements.

What was decided?

The Superintendent held that construction and additions in a house not registered as a condominium require the owners' consent, so in practice each side holds a right of veto. The neighbours' damage and split-off claims were dismissed, an injunction was granted concerning passage over the area designated for expropriation, and the neighbours were ordered to pay costs.

  • The Superintendent emphasised that construction and additions in such a house require the owners' consent, so that in practice each side holds a right of veto.
  • The neighbours claimed that they had consented only to construction under the original permit. An unsigned draft settlement agreement did not prove that claim.
  • The damage claims were dismissed on the basis of an opinion by a jointly agreed professional. All that remained were cosmetic repairs to the roof, which the client undertook to carry out.
  • The claim that a unit had been split off was dismissed: an advertisement for an "income-generating unit" does not prove that a separate residential unit exists.
  • An injunction was granted concerning passage over an area designated for expropriation: publication of an expropriation notice does not, in itself, give the authority any right until it takes possession.
  • The neighbours were ordered to pay costs.

Why is a written co-ownership agreement so important?

Where there is no condominium registration, the agreement between the co-owners is the document that determines who may build, where and to what extent. Oral agreements and unsigned drafts lead to exactly the kind of disputes seen in this case. A written agreement with a plan saves years of litigation.

What does the law say? In a registered condominium, the owners of three quarters of the apartments and two thirds of the common property may decide to take parts of the common property and attach them to an apartment in order to extend it, and to allocate the building rights required for that purpose (section 71B of the Land Law). Sections 77A and 77B of the Law apply this arrangement also to a house with at least two apartments that has not been registered as a condominium. But the decision requires this special majority, and without it construction and additions require the owners' consent, as the Superintendent held in the case.

Who has jurisdiction over such a dispute?

The Superintendent of Land Registration hears disputes between co-owners of land, even where the house has not been registered as a condominium. It is a professional tribunal with in-depth knowledge of real property law.

A decision of the Superintendent may be appealed to the District Court within 45 days of the day it was served (regulation 83 of the Land (Management and Registration) Regulations).

What about an advertisement for an "income-generating unit"?

A listing on a property website is not proof. To prove that a unit has been split off, it must be shown that a separate residential unit actually exists, with its own entrance, kitchen and independent use.

Sources

  • Land Law, 5729-1969: section 30(c) (a matter beyond ordinary management or use requires all co-owners' consent), section 71B (changes to the common property and building rights), sections 77A and 77B (application to a house not registered as a condominium). Hebrew.

Checked on 23 October 2026.

When should you consult a lawyer?

Co-owners of a house not registered as a condominium, with a dispute over construction? Send us the co-ownership agreement and the plan.

To arrange a call: 052-5927592, or on WhatsApp using the button on the website.

About the author

Amos Ilan is an advocate (Israel Bar no. 35320) and a notary (licence no. 214444). The office is at 17 Tzahal Street, Ness Ziona, and handles real estate transactions, construction defects, condominium disputes and civil litigation.

Disclaimer. This article describes a concluded case and is provided for general information only. It does not constitute legal advice and does not promise a similar outcome. Every case depends on its own facts and documents, so it is advisable to consult a lawyer before taking any step.

Questions and answers

Can the house be registered as a condominium retrospectively?

Yes, and it is usually advisable. Registration regulates the attachments, the shares in the common property and the bylaws.

My neighbour is building under a permit. Can he be stopped?

A building permit does not decide the property question, namely whether the co-owners consented. But it must be shown that there is no consent and that harm is being caused.

What happens where part of the land is designated for expropriation?

Until the authority actually takes possession, the rights in that area remain with the owners.

Need a lawyer or a notary?

A short initial consultation call, to understand whether and how we can help.

Call WhatsApp Form