Yes. Under section 37(a) of the Land Law, every co-owner is entitled at any time to demand the dissolution of co-ownership. There are exceptions, for example a co-ownership agreement that restricts this right, and the court decides how the dissolution is to be carried out: by division in kind or by sale.
Civil Disputes Lawyer
Neighbour disputes, dissolution of co-ownership, breach of contract and monetary claims, from the attempt to settle the dispute through to a decision by the court.
Under section 37 of the Land Law, 5729-1969, every co-owner of jointly owned land is entitled at any time to demand the dissolution of the co-ownership. When a contract is breached, section 2 of the Contracts (Remedies for Breach of Contract) Law, 5731-1970, gives the injured party the right to enforcement or rescission, and to damages in addition to, or instead of, those remedies.
A civil dispute in a 30-second video

The video loads from YouTube only after you click. Go to the video page and transcript
In the video: Chotmi versus Bureaucrat: a civil dispute in three rounds. First, the dispute is analysed and the prospects assessed, and sometimes it can be settled before it reaches court. Next, a reasoned statement of claim or statement of defence, discovery of documents and examination of witnesses. Finally, determined representation at the court hearing, through to a fair outcome that protects your rights.
When do you need a lawyer for a civil dispute?
It is advisable to see a lawyer when heirs or partners disagree over an apartment, in a dispute with a neighbour over a leak or construction, when the other party fails to perform a contract, when a debt remains unpaid, and when an extension is built on a house that has not been registered as a condominium.
- When siblings or partners who inherited an apartment cannot agree what to do with it.
- When water leaks from a neighbour's apartment, when an apartment is split without a permit, or when construction harms you.
- When the other party fails to perform a contract, or demands to rescind it.
- When a debt remains unpaid.
- When an extension is built on a house that has not been registered as a condominium.
Types of disputes and claims
The office handles commercial disputes, claims against insurance companies, monetary claims and debt collection, property damage and road accidents, tenancy and land disputes, dissolution of co-ownership, claims against renovation contractors, and neighbour disputes.
- Commercial disputes between businesses, between partners, and between suppliers and customers.
- Claims against insurance companies, where a claim has been rejected or less than the amount due has been paid.
- Claims for damage caused in road accidents.
- Monetary claims and debt collection.
- Claims for property damage, for example water damage or damage caused by a neighbour.
- Tenancy disputes and claims for eviction from leased premises.
- Disputes over ownership, possession and use of land.
- Dissolution of co-ownership of land and of an inherited apartment.
- Claims against renovation contractors and tradespeople who did not carry out the work properly.
- Neighbour disputes, both within a condominium and elsewhere: unpermitted building, noise and parking, businesses in residential streets and TAMA 38.
The other party breached the contract: what can you claim?
A party injured by a breach of contract may demand that the contract be performed (enforcement) or cancel it, and may claim damages in addition to either remedy or instead of it (section 2 of the Contracts (Remedies for Breach of Contract) Law, 5731-1970).
- Enforcement. The court orders the breaching party to perform the contract. Enforcement will not be granted where the contract cannot be performed, where it would compel personal work or personal service, where carrying it out requires an unreasonable degree of supervision, or where enforcement would be unjust in the circumstances (section 3).
- Cancellation. A fundamental breach allows immediate cancellation. For a breach that is not fundamental, you must first give an extension for performance, and you may cancel only if the contract is not performed within a reasonable time after it (sections 6 and 7). Cancellation is made by notice to the breaching party within a reasonable time (section 8), and each party then returns to the other what it received (section 9).
- Damages. For loss that the breaching party foresaw, or should have foreseen when the contract was made, as a probable result of the breach (section 10). Where the contract was cancelled because of a breach of an obligation to supply or accept property or a service, or where a sum of money was not paid, compensation is available without proof of loss (section 11). The court may also award compensation for non-pecuniary loss (section 13).
- Agreed damages. An amount fixed in advance in the contract is payable without proof of loss, but the court may reduce it if it was set without any reasonable relation to the loss that could have been foreseen (section 15).
- Mitigation. The breaching party is not liable for loss that the injured party could have prevented or reduced by reasonable means (section 14).
- Good faith. Parties must act in a customary manner and in good faith both in negotiations and in performing the contract (sections 12 and 39 of the Contracts (General Part) Law, 5733-1973). A party that breaches this duty in negotiations is liable for compensation even if no contract was signed.
What to do straight away: keep the contract and all the correspondence, document the loss and what was done to reduce it, and send a proper warning letter that gives an extension where one is required. Cancelling too early may turn the injured party into the one in breach. More in the articles The other party is breaching the sale contract and A warning letter before suing.
Anticipatory breach: what if the seller announces in advance that they will not perform?
A party who announces in advance that they will not perform the contract, or where the circumstances show that they will not be able or willing to perform it, is treated as being in breach even before the date set for performance. The other party may claim enforcement, cancellation or damages at that stage (section 17 of the Contracts (Remedies for Breach of Contract) Law).
A case from the office: Civil Case 30823-02-22 Raz et al. v. Mor et al. (Rishon LeZion Magistrates' Court). In August 2021 buyers signed a contract to purchase a resale apartment and paid the sellers ₪900,000, all of their own equity. About five months after signing, and before the delivery date, one of the sellers announced by phone that he did not intend to complete the deal. The sellers then failed to provide a letter of intent for discharging the mortgage, let the apartment to someone else for a period beyond the delivery date, and did not hand over the documents needed to transfer the rights. The buyers, represented by the office, sued for enforcement and for the agreed damages set in the contract, ₪219,500.
- Default judgment. The sellers did not file a proper defence in time, and in June 2022 judgment was given against them ordering delivery of the apartment and the transaction documents and payment of the agreed damages.
- Partial setting aside. In August 2022 the court set aside only the monetary part of the judgment, so that it would be heard on the merits, and kept the enforcement in place: the deal was to be completed within 30 days, and since the apartment was let, the court ruled that if it could not be handed over physically, possession would pass by assigning the lease to the buyers (regulation 131 of the Civil Procedure Regulations). The sellers were ordered to pay the costs of the application.
- Completing the deal. The sellers did not cooperate, and the deal was completed through a receiver appointed in enforcement proceedings. The buyers paid the balance of the price and the rights were transferred to them.
- Compensation. The dispute over the agreed damages continued, including a counterclaim by the sellers and an evidentiary hearing. In September 2025, on the court's proposal, the parties agreed that the sellers would pay the buyers ₪120,000, and the agreement was given the force of a judgment.
Lessons from the case: when the seller announces that they will not perform, there is no need to wait for the delivery date before suing; enforcement is possible even where the apartment has already been let to someone else; and agreed damages are not always recovered in full, because the court may reduce them (section 15 of the Remedies Law). Every case turns on its own facts.
Who is responsible for the breach? Frustration, mutual breach and third parties
Not every breach entitles you to enforcement and damages. Where the breach results from circumstances that the breaching party did not know of and should not have known of, and could not have prevented, and performing the contract is impossible or fundamentally different from what was agreed, there is no enforcement and no damages, and the court may order restitution (section 18 of the Remedies Law).
- Both parties breached. This is common in ongoing transactions and in building and renovation work. The questions are who breached first, which breach is fundamental, and how each breach affects the remedies available to each side.
- A third party caused the breach. A person who knowingly and without sufficient justification causes someone to breach a contract with another commits a tort against the injured party, provided the injured party suffered pecuniary loss (section 62 of the Torts Ordinance).
A money claim: which court and which track?
A money claim of up to ₪2,500,000 is filed in the Magistrates' Court (section 51 of the Courts Law), and above that in the District Court. A claim of up to ₪75,000 is heard in the Magistrates' Court on the expedited track (regulation 78 of the Civil Procedure Regulations, 5779-2018), and an individual can file a small claim without a lawyer.
| Small claim | Expedited track | Regular track | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amount | Up to ₪39,900 as of 2026 (section 60 of the Courts Law) | Up to ₪75,000 | Above ₪75,000 |
| Who may sue | Individuals only | Any claimant | Any claimant |
| Representation | As a rule without a lawyer, unless the court permits | Permitted | Permitted |
| Statement of defence | 30 days | 45 days | 60 days |
| Appeal | By leave only | As of right | As of right |
The expedited track does not apply to claims for bodily injury or to claims under the Road Accident Victims Compensation Law, and it also applies to claims for eviction from rented property.
- A defendant who did not file a defence. The court may give judgment on the basis of the statement of claim alone, or require the claimant to prove the claim (regulation 130). The summary procedure that existed under the previous regulations no longer exists.
- Linkage and interest. The court may award interest and linkage differentials on the amount, as a rule from the day the claim was filed, and at its discretion from another date, but not before the cause of action arose (section 2 of the Adjudication of Interest and Linkage Law, 5721-1961). Where an obligation to pay money was breached, the Remedies Law gives interest from the day of the breach even without proof of loss (section 11(b)). To calculate: linkage and interest calculator.
- Court fee. In a claim for a fixed sum the fee is paid in two halves: the first on filing, and the second up to 20 days before the date set for the first hearing. A settlement, mediation or withdrawal before the end of the third pre-trial session entitles you to a partial refund of the fee, and a default judgment exempts you from the second half (regulation 6 of the Courts (Fees) Regulations). To calculate: court fee calculator.
- Is it worth it? Before suing, check whether the defendant has assets or income to collect from, whether there is a guarantee or other security, and whether there is a risk that assets will disappear, in which case a temporary attachment can be requested. A claim that is dismissed may leave the claimant liable for the other side's costs.
How the case itself runs, from the statement of claim to judgment, is explained in the article How a civil case runs, step by step, and the procedural deadlines in the civil procedure deadlines calculator.
Torts and negligence: who pays for damage to property?
A person who causes damage by negligence must pay compensation. Negligence is an act or omission that a reasonable and prudent person would not have committed in the same circumstances, or using less skill and care than a reasonable professional in the same field would have used (sections 35 and 36 of the Torts Ordinance [New Version]).
- Professional negligence. A contractor, renovator, appraiser or other service provider who fell below the accepted professional standard. An expert opinion is usually needed to prove the departure from that standard and the damage.
- Damage to property. A leak from a neighbouring apartment, damage from works on a neighbouring property, breakage or loss. See A leak from the upstairs neighbour and A claim against a renovation contractor.
- Trespass and nuisance. Unlawful entry onto land or interference with it (section 29), and substantial interference with the reasonable use of property (private nuisance, section 44).
- Contributory fault. If the injured party was also at fault, the compensation is reduced according to their share of responsibility (section 68).
- Insurance company. When an insurer rejects a claim or pays less than is due, it can be sued, and sometimes the person who caused the damage as well.
Renting: a deposit not returned, defects and eviction
In a residential lease, the security a landlord may require is capped at the lower of the rent for one third of the lease period and three months' rent, and at the end of the lease it must be returned within 60 days of the apartment being returned, or once the tenant's debts have been paid, whichever is later (section 25J of the Rental and Borrowing Law, 5731-1971).
- Drawing on the security. Allowed only in the cases set out in the law: unpaid rent, defects the tenant is responsible for and did not repair, unpaid running costs, and failure to vacate, and only after advance notice that gives the tenant a chance to put things right.
- Condition of the apartment. The landlord must hand over an apartment that is suitable and fit for living in. Handing over an apartment that is not fit to live in is a breach of contract (sections 25E and 25F). These provisions apply to most residential leases, with exceptions set out in the law.
- Eviction. A claim for eviction from rented property runs on a fast track: a defence within 30 days, and a hearing within 30 days of the last defence being filed (regulation 81). See Claim for eviction from rented property.
- What to bring. The lease, proof of payments, the handover record and photos from the start and end of the lease, and correspondence about defects.
Money paid by mistake and disputes between partners: unjust enrichment
A person who received money, property or a service without a legal right to it must return it, even where there is no contract between the parties (section 1 of the Unjust Enrichment Law, 5739-1979). The court may exempt them from restitution, in whole or in part, where it would be unjust in the circumstances (section 2).
- Examples. A bank transfer to the wrong account and paying the same invoice twice.
- A dispute between partners. In a business or a jointly owned asset: sharing profits, expenses one partner bore alone, a partner who uses the asset and keeps the others out, and dissolving the partnership. For jointly owned land, see the section on dissolution of co-ownership further down this page.
What do you need to prove in a civil claim, and how?
As a rule, the claimant must prove the claim on the balance of probabilities, meaning that their version is more likely than the defendant's. In practice, the documents, correspondence, expert opinions and witnesses decide the case.
- Documents. The contract, quotes, invoices and proof of payment.
- Correspondence. Emails and WhatsApp messages, kept in full and with dates.
- Recordings. Recording a conversation you take part in is not eavesdropping, because eavesdropping means listening without the consent of any of the parties to the conversation (section 1 of the Eavesdropping Law, 5739-1979). There are exceptions, including a recording made in order to commit an offence or cause harm, which is prohibited (section 3). Keep the original file.
- Expert opinion. On a professional question such as the quality of work, the value of property or the extent of damage.
- Witnesses. Evidence in chief, followed by cross-examination. See The art of cross-examination.
What should you do before going to court?
Before suing, organise the material, check the deadlines and try to settle. A short list:
- Gather the contract, the correspondence and proof of payment, and arrange them by date.
- Write a short timeline of the events.
- Document the damage: photos, repair quotes and invoices.
- Check the limitation date.
- Send a proper warning letter.
- Check whether the other side has assets or insurance to collect from.
- Consider negotiation or mediation before filing.
How the work proceeds
The work proceeds in four stages: establishing the facts and documents; attempting a settlement by a letter of demand, negotiation or mediation; legal proceedings in the appropriate forum through to a decision; and finally enforcement of the judgment or of the settlement.
- Establishing the facts and documents. What was signed, what was registered, what actually happened and what has already been said in writing. From this follow the available remedies and the appropriate forum.
- Attempting a settlement. A letter of demand, negotiation or mediation. In a dispute between neighbours or family members, an agreed arrangement saves time and leaves room for the relationship to continue.
- Legal proceedings. A claim in the appropriate forum: the Magistrates' Court, the District Court or the Superintendent of Land Registration, conducted through to a decision.
- Enforcement. Enforcement of the judgment or of the settlement and, in a dissolution of co-ownership: division, sale, or the purchase of a co-owner's share.
What should you bring to the meeting?
Bring the contracts and agreements between the parties, the correspondence with the other party, and records of payments and debts. Where a property is involved, also bring a Land Registry extract, inheritance order or probate order, and where property has been damaged, photographs and expert opinions.
- Contracts and agreements between the parties.
- A Land Registry extract, inheritance order or probate order, where a property is involved.
- Photographs and expert opinions, where property has been damaged.
- Correspondence with the other party.
- Records of payments and debts.
Timeline and cost
Timetable: an initial assessment of the situation is given in the first conversation. If the documents are sent in advance, the assessment is better founded. The length of the proceedings depends on the forum and on the complexity of the case. An attempt to settle the dispute before a claim is filed usually takes weeks; the claim itself takes considerably longer.
Cost: the fee is set in a written fee agreement, after the case has been reviewed. Court fees, expert opinions and other expenses are paid separately.
Settlement by agreement or judicial decision
In a settlement by agreement the parties decide, a flexible solution can be reached, the relationship is usually better preserved, and the settlement can be given the effect of a judgment. In a judicial decision, the court or the Superintendent decides according to the remedies available under the law.
| Subject | Settlement by agreement (negotiation or mediation) | Judicial decision |
|---|---|---|
| Who decides | The parties | The court or the Superintendent |
| Flexibility of the solution | The parties may agree on a solution that a court would not have ordered | Limited to the remedies available under the law |
| Future relationship | Usually better preserved | Often damaged |
| Enforcement | The settlement can be given the effect of a judgment | A judgment |
Dissolution of co-ownership: division in kind or sale?
Land that can be divided is dissolved by division in kind, and the court may order balancing payments (Section 39 of the Land Law). Where division is not possible, or would cause substantial loss, the land is sold and the proceeds are divided between the co-owners (Section 40).
For a residential apartment, and especially an inherited one, the practical outcome is almost always a sale. The central question is therefore how to manage the sale so as to obtain the highest possible price, and sometimes whether one co-owner buys out the others. More in the articles Dissolving co-ownership of an apartment inherited by siblings and Judgment already at the pre-trial stage. The full guide, including use fees, sale through a receiver and tax: Partition of co-owned real estate.
A dispute in a condominium: where do you turn?
A dispute between apartment owners over their rights and obligations under the bylaws or under the provisions listed in Section 72 of the Land Law, such as use of the common property and sharing of expenses, is heard by the Superintendent of Land Registration.
An ordinary tort claim, such as damage from a leak from a neighbouring apartment, is heard in court. Choosing the right forum from the start saves months.
Limitation in a civil dispute
As with any claim: seven years, and 15 years for land (Section 5 of the Prescription Law). The right to demand dissolution of co-ownership does not become time-barred, because under Section 37 of the Land Law every co-owner may demand dissolution at any time.
Where the facts that make up the cause of action were unknown to the claimant for reasons beyond their control, the period starts on the day they became known (section 8 of the Prescription Law). In tort, where the damage was not discovered on the day it occurred, the period starts on the day of discovery, but the claim is barred in any event ten years after the damage occurred (section 89 of the Torts Ordinance).
Contact us to review your dispute
If you are in a dispute or facing legal proceedings, it is worth reviewing the position early, before any deadlines pass. We will be glad to hear the details and explain the options.
Questions and answers
Can I compel a sibling or co-owner to dissolve the co-ownership of an apartment?
The other party has breached the contract. What can I claim?
Under section 2 of the Contracts (Remedies for Breach of Contract) Law, the injured party is entitled to sue for enforcement or to rescind the contract, and to claim damages in addition to, or instead of, either of those remedies.
A dispute with a neighbour in the building: court or Superintendent?
It depends on the nature of the dispute. A dispute between apartment owners concerning their rights and obligations under the condominium bylaws and under the law is heard by the Superintendent of Land Registration (section 72 of the Land Law). An ordinary tort claim is brought in court.
Can the court order the jointly owned apartment to be sold?
Yes. Where the apartment cannot be divided in kind, dissolution is by sale and division of the proceeds (Section 40 of the Land Law).
A leak from the neighbour: the Superintendent or the court?
A claim for the damage itself is filed in court. A dispute over repairing shared pipes or sharing condominium expenses may fall within the jurisdiction of the Superintendent of Land Registration.
What is the difference between a fundamental breach and one that is not fundamental?
A fundamental breach is one that a reasonable person would not have entered into the contract had they foreseen it, or a breach that the contract defines as fundamental. It allows immediate cancellation. For a breach that is not fundamental, you must first give an extension for performance (sections 6 and 7 of the Remedies Law).
Can I get compensation without proving loss?
Yes, in two main cases: agreed damages fixed in advance in the contract (section 15 of the Remedies Law), and compensation under section 11 where the contract was cancelled because of a breach of an obligation to supply or accept property or a service, or where a sum of money was not paid.
The defendant did not file a defence. What happens?
The court may give judgment on the basis of the statement of claim alone, or require the claimant to prove all or part of the claim (regulation 130 of the Civil Procedure Regulations).
I paid a person or company by mistake. Can I get the money back?
As a rule, yes. Under the Unjust Enrichment Law, a person who received money without a legal right to it must return it, even where there is no contract between you. The court may exempt them from restitution where it would be unjust in the circumstances.
The landlord is not returning the deposit. What do I do?
In a residential lease, the security must be returned within 60 days of the apartment being returned, or once your debts under the lease have been paid, whichever is later (section 25J of the Rental and Borrowing Law). Send a written demand with a record of the apartment's condition, and if there is no answer, file a claim. If the amount does not exceed the small claims ceiling, you can sue in the Small Claims Court.
What is the risk if the claim is dismissed?
The court may order the claimant to pay the other side's costs. That is why the prospects, the evidence and the ability to collect are checked before filing.
Can I use a recording of a conversation as evidence?
As a rule, yes, if you are a party to the conversation, because that is not eavesdropping. There are exceptions, for example a recording made in order to commit an offence or cause harm (sections 1 and 3 of the Eavesdropping Law). Keep the original file.
The seller says he will not sell me the apartment, but the delivery date has not arrived yet. Can I sue now?
Yes. Under section 17 of the Remedies Law, a party who has shown that they will not perform the contract is in breach even before the due date, and the buyer may claim enforcement, cancellation or damages now. The court will not order an obligation to be performed before its due date.
How long does a civil claim take?
It depends on the track, the complexity and the court's workload. On the expedited track the regulations require a hearing no later than six months after the last defence is filed (regulation 80). On the regular track there is no such fixed date.
Related articles and pages
- Dissolving co-ownership of an apartment inherited by siblings
- A leak from the upstairs neighbour
- The neighbour split the house into separate units
- Building and extending in a house not registered as a condominium
- The other party is in breach of the sale agreement
- Litigation
- Superintendent of Land Registration
More on litigation
Need a lawyer or a notary?
A short initial consultation call, to understand whether and how we can help.
Last updated:
