The Art of Cross-Examination
Good cross-examination is almost never thrilling. It is quiet, measured, and built so that the witness arrives on his own at the place we wanted to bring him to. Cross-examination is the questioning of a witness by the opposing party, after the examination-in-chief. It is decided in the preparation before the hearing: reading the affidavit against all the evidence, and closed questions whose answers are known in advance.
Cross-examination in a 30-second video

The video loads from YouTube only after you click. Go to the video page and transcript
In the video: cross-examination is decided before the hearing: the affidavit is checked against all the evidence, and every contradiction becomes a question. Ask closed questions, one fact per question, and never ask a question to which you do not know the answer. When cross-examining an expert witness, the gaps lie in the underlying assumptions: what he relied on and what he measured himself.
When is cross-examination decided?
Most of what looks like brilliant improvisation in the courtroom is the result of work done weeks earlier: reading the witness's affidavit against all the evidence in the case and marking every statement that does not square with a document, with correspondence, with an expert opinion or with earlier testimony of the same witness.
Each such contradiction yields one question, sometimes two. An hour of cross-examination is built from dozens of such items, arranged in an order that keeps the witness from seeing where it is heading.
What are the ground rules of cross-examination?
Ask closed questions only, and only questions to which you know the answer, with one fact per question. Do not argue with the witness, stop once the answer has been obtained, and save the argument for closing submissions.
- Closed questions only: a question that lets the witness explain is an opportunity handed to him to correct himself. A closed question allows only yes or no.
- Never ask a question to which you do not know the answer: there is no room for curiosity in cross-examination.
- One fact per question: a compound question invites an evasive answer.
- Do not argue with the witness: arguing hands him the stage and diminishes the examiner in the eyes of the court.
- Know when to stop: once the answer has been obtained, every further question merely allows it to be softened.
- Save the argument for closing submissions: in cross-examination you collect bricks; you do not build the wall.
How is cross-examining an expert witness different?
Cross-examining a witness who gives expert opinion evidence, such as a real estate appraiser or an engineer, is conducted not through legal questions but through professional ones. The gaps usually lie in the underlying assumptions: what data he relied on, what he measured himself and what he received from the party that engaged him, which standards he applied, and what would have changed had the basic assumption been different.
This calls for command of the engineering or appraisal material itself, not only of the rules of evidence. It is also the stage at which we examine what the same witness said in earlier cases, and whether his opinions have drawn judicial criticism in the past.
What do the rules provide?
The tactical rules rest on a fixed framework in the Civil Procedure Regulations, 5779-2018 (Hebrew):
- Order of examination: the party who called the witness examines in chief, the opposing party may cross-examine, and re-examination is limited to matters arising from the cross-examination that remained unclear (regulation 67(c)). What is not cured in re-examination stays.
- An affidavit without cross-examination is not evidence: an affidavit in lieu of examination in chief counts as evidence only if the deponent appeared for cross-examination (regulation 178(b)). So the decision whether to cross-examine, or to waive it, is a tactical decision in itself.
- Experts: a party who filed an expert opinion must ensure the expert appears for cross-examination, unless the other side waived it (regulation 87(h)). The opinion is accompanied by a list of the sources the expert relied on (regulation 87(g)), which is the starting point for preparing the cross-examination.
- Continuity: as a rule, cross-examination takes place immediately after examination in chief (regulation 64(b)), so preparation must be complete before the hearing, not after it.
- Objections: an objection to a question is reasoned at once and decided at once, unless the court defers its ruling (regulation 68). The court itself may put any question to the witness (regulation 69(b)).
The regulations were checked on 23 October 2026.
Which mistakes recur?
The common mistakes are cross-examination that runs too long, repeating the examination-in-chief, a single open question that wipes out good work, ignoring the court's reaction, and having no fallback plan for when the witness changes direction.
- Cross-examination that runs too long: a focused quarter of an hour is better than two hours that blur what was achieved.
- Repeating the examination-in-chief: gives the witness an opportunity to reinforce his version.
- A single open question: is enough to wipe out an hour of good work.
- Ignoring the court's reaction: cross-examination is aimed at the judge, not at the witness, and not at the client sitting in the courtroom.
- No fallback plan: when a witness changes direction, you need to have prepared for it in advance.
What does it give the client?
Thorough preparation for cross-examination has an effect even when the case ends in a settlement. A party that knows its witness will be cross-examined on every contradiction usually comes to the negotiating table in a more realistic frame of mind.
Nothing in this article constitutes legal advice or a substitute for it.
Need a lawyer or a notary?
A short initial consultation call, to understand whether and how we can help.
