Initially, whoever commissions it. In a judgment or a settlement, reimbursement of the expert's fees may be obtained.
Engineer's expert opinion on construction defects: what it should contain, and when to commission one
In a construction defects claim, the engineering expert opinion is the central evidence. It sets out each defect, its source, the repair method and its cost. A good expert opinion is written from the outset for the court, not for the resident: precise, reasoned, and based on standards and on the specification.
An engineer's opinion in a 30-second video

The video loads from YouTube only after you click. Go to the video page and transcript
In the video: In a construction defects claim, this is the key evidence. Order it before the inspection period of a material item ends, or when the contractor rejects the demand. For each defect separately: description, location, photo and cause, and a detailed repair method with its cost. It is written for the court: precise and reasoned, and based on standards and on the specification.
When should an expert opinion be commissioned?
It is advisable to commission an expert opinion before the inspection period for a material item expires, when the contractor rejects the demand, when the defect recurs after repair, and before a lawsuit. In a non-medical claim, it may be attached to the statement of claim.
- Before the inspection period for a material item expires. During the warranty period the burden of proof shifts to the purchaser, and an expert opinion prepared during the inspection period is worth a great deal (on the periods: inspection and warranty period calculator).
- When the contractor rejects the demand or claims that the defect was caused by the use of the apartment.
- When the defect recurs after repair, in order to document the failure before an independent repair at the contractor's expense.
- Before a lawsuit. In a non-medical claim, an expert opinion may be attached to the statement of claim (regulation 15(b) of the Civil Procedure Regulations), so that the case is built from the outset.
What should the expert opinion include?
The expert opinion should include the expert's details and the testing method, and for each defect separately: description, location, photograph, the requirement breached and the source of the defect. It also requires a detailed repair method and a bill of quantities with the cost of each item, VAT and engineering supervision.
- The expert's details, education and experience, and the date of the visit to the apartment.
- The testing method and instruments: moisture meter, thermal camera, flood test, measurements and, where necessary, destructive testing.
- For each defect separately: description, location, photograph, and the requirement breached: the specification, the plans, an official standard or the building regulations.
- The source of the defect: design, workmanship or materials. During the warranty period this is exactly what the purchaser must prove.
- A detailed repair method, and not merely "to be repaired".
- A bill of quantities and the cost of each item, and at the end a summary, VAT and engineering supervision.
An expert opinion submitted to the court is prepared in accordance with section 24 of the Evidence Ordinance, and is accompanied by a list of the sources on which the expert relies (regulation 87(g) of the Civil Procedure Regulations).
Common mistakes
The common mistakes are "to be repaired" without a method and without a cost, prices without a source, mixing a defect with a matter of taste, ignoring the specification and the contract, and a single inspection in summer for a damp defect that appears only in winter.
- "To be repaired" without a method and without a cost. The court cannot award a sum that has not been proved.
- Prices without a source, or without distinguishing between labour and materials.
- Mixing a defect with a matter of taste, which weakens the entire expert opinion in the eyes of the court-appointed expert.
- Failure to address the specification and the contract. A deviation from the specification is a non-conformity even where the work meets the standard (section 4(a)(1) of the Sale (Apartments) Law).
- A single inspection in summer for a damp defect that appears only in winter.
Court-appointed expert
In construction defects cases, where there is a gap between the parties' expert opinions, which is very common, the court may appoint its own expert (regulation 88 of the Civil Procedure Regulations). The expert inspects the apartment, and his opinion is usually decisive. It is therefore important to know two things:
- Where the court-appointed expert is appointed with the consent of the parties, this is regarded, unless the court orders otherwise, as consent that the parties' expert opinions submitted earlier will not be admitted in evidence (regulation 88(d)).
- Before the expert's visit, the apartment and the documentation are prepared, and questions of clarification are put to him where necessary. Defects that he did not see, or did not understand, will not be included in his opinion.
Why a lawyer who understands engineering?
The case is often decided on the technical details: whether the crack is in a load-bearing element, where the damp is coming from, and what the correct repair method is. When the lawyer understands the language of engineering, he can review the expert opinion before it is submitted, draft precise questions of clarification for the expert, and cross-examine the other side's expert on the weak points.
Which standard applies?
The inspection is made according to the version of the standard or regulation that applies to the apartment, and a change made after delivery is irrelevant. Where the change came before delivery, the question has not been finally decided, so a good opinion states, for each defect, which version applies and why.
Standards and building regulations change, and an engineer inspecting an apartment must know which version applies. In CA 6092/00 Kedouri Urban Development v. Otmazgin (7 October 2002), the Supreme Court held that a change in a regulation after delivery is irrelevant: the contractor cannot be required to meet a requirement not yet enacted, nor should it benefit from a relaxation made after it was paid in full. Which date governs when the change came before delivery (contract, permit, construction or delivery) was left open. In CC (Tel Aviv Magistrates) 48055-03-14 Sinai v. Donitz-Kiryat HaOmanim (7 December 2017), the Court held that the relevant date is the specification date or the building permit date, whichever is later, not delivery. A good opinion therefore states, for each defect, which version of the standard or regulation applies and why.
The status of the standard matters too. An official standard binds by law, and a standard that is not official usually becomes part of the contract through the specification, which refers to the requirements of the Israeli standard. A good opinion states, for each defect, the standard number, the clause and the measurement, not just "contrary to the standard". The standards that recur in construction defects claims are listed in the article Building standards and construction defects.
Defects not listed in the statement of claim
Compensation can sometimes be obtained even for defects that the court expert found and that were not included in the statement of claim, depending on the circumstances. It is therefore advisable to include a clause on hidden defects in the statement of claim, and to ask the expert in writing to address every defect found.
The court expert often finds defects not included in the statement of claim. In CA 1051/03 Ulpan Reuven v. K.M.B.K (1 August 2005), the Supreme Court held that this depends on the circumstances, and that in that case compensation could be awarded for them too: the expert was appointed by agreement, the claim included a general clause on hidden defects "to be discovered in the future", and the buyers' counsel asked the expert in writing to address every defect found. Two practical recommendations follow: include such a clause in the claim, and ask in the appointment or in a letter to the expert that every defect found be addressed.
Case law and sources
- Sale (Apartments) Law, 5733-1973: section 4(a)(1).
- CA 6092/00 Kedouri Urban Development Ltd. v. Otmazgin (7 October 2002), para. 7.
- CA 1051/03 Ulpan Reuven v. K.M.B.K Development Ltd. (1 August 2005).
- CC (Tel Aviv Magistrates) 48055-03-14 Sinai v. Donitz-Kiryat HaOmanim Ltd. (7 December 2017).
The judgments were read in full and the texts checked against the sources on 23 October 2026. This is general information and not advice on a specific matter.
About the author
Amos Ilan, Advocate, is a lawyer (Bar No. 35320) and a notary (licence 214444). The office is at 17 Tzahal Street, Nes Ziona, and handles real estate transactions, construction defects, condominium disputes and civil litigation. Alongside his legal work he has practical knowledge, not based on formal training, of engineering, appraisal and electrical and building systems, and he personally conducts the cross-examination of experts in construction defects cases.
Questions and answers
Who pays for the expert opinion?
Can a home inspection carried out before delivery be used?
A home inspection report from delivery is important documentation of the condition of the apartment, but a lawsuit usually requires an expert opinion prepared in accordance with section 24 of the Evidence Ordinance, with a repair method and cost.
What if the court-appointed expert made a mistake?
Questions of clarification may be put to him and, in appropriate cases, he may be cross-examined in court. It is advisable to do so on the basis of a professional review of his opinion.
Need a lawyer or a notary?
A short initial consultation call, to understand whether and how we can help.
