You have found a defect in your new apartment. What now?
Most of what decides the outcome of a construction defects case is settled in the first year, long before anyone talks about a lawsuit. The questions are when the defect was discovered, when you gave notice of it, and who has to prove what.
An inspection period is the period that the Sale (Apartments) Law, 5733-1973 sets for each type of defect, during which the seller is responsible for the repair unless the seller proves that the defect was caused by the buyer.
The first year in a new apartment in a 30-second video

The video loads from YouTube only after you click. Go to the video page and transcript
In the video: Most of what decides a defects case is settled in the first year. Document every defect: what, where and when it was discovered. Dated photos are worth a lot. Each item has its own inspection period, usually from one to 7 years, and the warranty starts at the end of that item's inspection period. Notify the contractor in writing, on time. The inspection-period calculator on the site shows the periods.
Which two periods does the law set?
The Sale (Apartments) Law, 5733-1973, distinguishes between two periods. Section 4(c) defines the "inspection period" as the period fixed in the Schedule to the Law, beginning when the apartment is placed at the purchaser's disposal, and the "warranty period" as 3 years beginning at the end of the inspection period.
Note a point that is almost always missed: the warranty period does not begin on the day of delivery but at the end of the inspection period for the item concerned. Because each item has its own inspection period, the warranty period also begins and ends on a different date for each item.
What are the inspection periods under the Schedule to the Law?
The inspection period ranges from one to 7 years, according to the type of defect in the Schedule: for example, 2 years for flooring, 4 years for piping and waterproofing, and 5 years for cracks wider than 1.5 mm. For a fundamental non-conformity, section 4(a)(4) sets a period of 20 years.
- Metalwork and joinery, including aluminium and plastic: 2 years
- Interior flooring and cladding, including subsidence and wear: 2 years
- Failure in the functioning and durability of machinery and boilers: 3 years
- Yard landscaping, including subsidence: 3 years
- Failure in the functioning and durability of thermal insulation components: 3 years
- Failure of piping systems, including water, heating, gutters, waste water and sewage, including leaks: 4 years
- Failure of the building's waterproofing, including underground spaces, walls, ceilings and roofs: 4 years
- Cracks wider than 1.5 mm in non-load-bearing elements: 5 years
- Detachment, peeling or crumbling of exterior cladding: 7 years
- Any other non-conformity that is not a fundamental non-conformity: one year
This list is exhaustive, and that is an important practical point. Damp, for example, is not a separate item in the Schedule: it falls under waterproofing or under piping, and in either case the period is 4 years. By contrast, cracked plaster that does not meet the definition of cracks, or a lift malfunction, is not listed in the Schedule and therefore falls under the general one-year item. The difference between 4 years and one year is the whole case.
Damp is also one of the most common and most troublesome defects. In an interview with ynet on construction defects, Advocate Amos Ilan set out its usual sources, from faulty waterproofing between floors and on balconies to poor installation around rooftop piping, and explained that with defects of this kind the remedy usually sought is an actual repair rather than monetary compensation: "Suffering from construction defects in your apartment? Here is how to sue and obtain compensation" (ynet Economy, 5 February 2021).
In addition, section 4(a)(4) sets an inspection period of 20 years for a fundamental non-conformity, that is, a non-conformity in the foundations, in the structural frame or in anything affecting the stability and safety of the building. Section 4(a)(5) adds that even after all the periods have expired, the seller remains liable if the purchaser proves that the non-conformity originates in the design, the workmanship or the materials.
Who has to prove what?
During the inspection period, under section 4(a)(2), it is enough that a non-conformity has been discovered. The seller is liable unless it proves that the non-conformity was caused by an act or omission of the purchaser. The burden is on the seller.
During the warranty period, under section 4(a)(3), the position is reversed: it is the purchaser who must prove that the non-conformity originates in the design, the workmanship or the materials. In practice this means an engineer's report, and sometimes also opening up part of the building to show what lies beneath, in other words destructive testing.
That is why a defect discovered in the last month of the inspection period should be handled quite differently from an identical defect discovered a month later.
In practice, we file claims in both the inspection period and the warranty period together with an expert opinion confirming that the defect exists, rather than relying on the distinction in the burden of proof alone.
When must you give notice of the defect?
Section 4A of the Law sets two routes for notice. A non-conformity that could have been discovered when the apartment was placed at the purchaser's disposal, that is, at the handover inspection, requires notice within one year of that date. A non-conformity that could not have been discovered on a reasonable inspection requires notice within a reasonable time after the purchaser discovered it.
- The notice deadline (Section 4A(a)(1)): a non-conformity that could have been discovered at delivery must be notified to the seller within one year from the date the apartment was placed at the buyer's disposal. This is a deadline for notice, not an inspection period. Section 4A.
- The inspection period (Section 4(c) and the Schedule): a period set according to the type of defect. In the 2011 version of the law it ranges from one to 7 years: for example flooring 2 years, piping and waterproofing 4 years, and exterior cladding 7 years. During this period there is a presumption that the non-conformity is the seller's responsibility (Section 4(a)(2)). One year is only the inspection period for "any other non-conformity" (item 10 of the Schedule).
What this means in practice: the handover protocol is not a formality. Everything recorded in it is documented and dated, and anything that was neither recorded in it nor reported in the first year may fall by the wayside. A verbal comment to a representative on site is not notice you can prove 2 years later.
A rule of thumb: every defect in writing, with a date and a photograph, sent to the address for notices specified in the contract. Even if everyone agrees the developer will repair it, the written notice is what will remain.
What is the developer's right to repair, and what are its limits?
Section 4B(a) provides that the purchaser must give the seller a proper opportunity to repair, and the seller must repair within a reasonable time. Going straight to a monetary claim without allowing a repair is a mistake, and it will cost you in legal costs.
This right is not unlimited, however. Section 4B(b) allows the purchaser to carry out the repair at the seller's expense in two situations: where the non-conformity has recurred after the seller has already repaired it once or more within 2 years from the date of the purchaser's notice, or where the repair is urgent and the seller has not carried it out within a reasonable time after notice.
This also tells you what is important to document: not only the defect but every round of repairs. When they came, what they did, and when the problem returned. Three documented rounds of waterproofing work are far stronger evidence than a report describing damp as it is today.
What should you do in practice?
Go through the handover protocol with someone who understands construction, record every defect in writing with a date and a photograph, check against the Schedule which item it belongs to, and document every round of repairs. A verbal promise from a site manager is not enough.
- Go through the handover protocol with someone who understands construction, and do not sign it blank.
- Record every defect in writing, with a date and a photograph, and keep a copy yourself.
- Check against the Schedule which item the defect belongs to, because that determines the period and the burden of proof.
- Allow repairs, but document every round: the date, the scope, and what came back.
- Before the inspection period for a significant item ends, consider commissioning an inspection by an engineer.
- Do not rely on a verbal promise from a site manager. What is not in writing did not happen.
Bottom line
In construction defects cases, the winner is usually the party whose file is better documented, not the one whose defect is more serious. The deadlines are fixed by law, they differ from item to item, and they run from the day you received the keys. It is worth knowing where you stand before the period closes.
Nothing in this article constitutes legal advice or a substitute for it, and every case is assessed on its own circumstances.
Need a lawyer or a notary?
A short initial consultation call, to understand whether and how we can help.
