As a rule, the Law requires the buyer to give the contractor a reasonable opportunity to repair a repairable defect. The exceptions are a defect that recurs after repair within two years of the notice, and an urgent repair that was not carried out within a reasonable time. In any event, it is advisable to take advice before forgoing the repair.
Repair or monetary compensation for construction defects: when the contractor loses the right to repair
The Sale (Apartments) Law gives the contractor a reasonable opportunity to repair a defect before the matter turns to money (section 4B(a)). This right is limited: where a defect recurs after repair within two years of the notice, or where an urgent repair was not carried out within a reasonable time, the buyer may carry out the repair and the contractor will bear the cost (section 4B(b)).
Repair or compensation for defects in a 30-second video

The video loads from YouTube only after you click. Go to the video page and transcript
In the video: A question we hear a lot: the contractor repaired, and the leak came back. What now? In two situations you may repair at the contractor's expense: the defect recurred after a repair, within two years of the notice, or an urgent repair was not carried out within a reasonable time. Document before the repair, get an expert opinion and quotes, and keep the invoices.
The rule: an opportunity to repair comes first
Where a repairable defect is discovered, the buyer must give the contractor a reasonable opportunity to repair it, and the contractor must carry out the repair within a reasonable time. Going straight to a monetary claim, without allowing a repair, is a mistake that may cost you in legal costs and in a reduction of the compensation.
A reasonable opportunity means written notice, a detailed list of the defects, and willingness to arrange a date for the works. Not every delay by the contractor extends its right. It must carry out the repair within a reasonable time.
The two situations in which you may repair at the contractor's expense
You may repair at the contractor's expense in two situations: when the defect recurred after the contractor repaired it, within two years of the date of notice, and when an urgent repair was not carried out within a reasonable time of the notice. For the expense to be recognised, document the defect, obtain an expert opinion and quotations, and keep the invoices.
- The defect has recurred. The non-conformity recurred and was discovered after the contractor had repaired it once or more, within two years beginning on the date of the buyer's notice.
- An urgent repair was not carried out. The repair is urgent, and the contractor did not carry it out within a reasonable time from the date of the notice. For example, an active leak, or a defect that endangers safety.
In both situations the buyer may carry out the repair, and the contractor will bear the cost of the repair. For the expense to be recognised, document the defect before the repair, obtain an expert opinion and quotations, and keep the invoices.
When is monetary compensation preferable to a repair?
Monetary compensation is preferable when the contractor has already tried and failed, when the defects are extensive and another contractor under supervision will do a better job, when the house committee wishes to choose a contractor and manage the works in the common property itself, or when the contractor is in financial difficulty.
- When the contractor has already tried and failed, and confidence in its ability to repair has been lost.
- When the defects are extensive, and another contractor, under supervision, will do a better job.
- In the common property, when the house committee wishes to choose a contractor and manage the works itself.
- When the contractor is in financial difficulty, and the likelihood that it will carry out a thorough repair is low.
Two examples from cases we handled, one in each direction. In the case of the building committee of three buildings in Rehovot, about 100 buyers, the proceeding ended in a settlement in which the developer paid NIS 2,978,750 and the committee carried out the repairs itself (case details). In a damp case in a TAMA 38 project an actual repair was chosen instead, under the supervision of a court expert and with a three-winter warranty, alongside a payment of NIS 20,000 towards costs (case details).
What does monetary compensation consist of?
Monetary compensation includes the cost of repair according to the expert opinion, including VAT, engineering supervision, mental distress, loss of value where a defect remains that cannot be fully repaired, and ancillary expenses such as alternative accommodation and expert fees. Every component requires proof, and a component that has not been proven will not be awarded.
- The cost of repair according to the expert opinion, including VAT, since the buyer will actually pay it.
- Engineering supervision of the repair works.
- Mental distress, according to the extent of the defects, their duration and their effect on life in the apartment.
- Loss of value, where a defect remains that cannot be fully repaired.
- Ancillary expenses, such as alternative accommodation during extensive repairs, and expert fees.
Every component requires proof: an expert opinion, quotations and receipts. A component that has not been proven will not be awarded.
Waivers and "completion of repairs" confirmations
Contractors often ask buyers to sign a confirmation that the repairs have been completed, or a waiver in return for a repair or a payment. Under Section 7A(a) of the Law, the provisions of the Law may not be contracted out of except in the buyer's favour. Even so, such a signature can complicate proof later on. Before signing, check exactly what has been repaired and what remains open.
When is the contractor not entitled to another chance?
Where the contractor was given an adequate opportunity to repair before the claim was filed and did not use it, or tried and failed, the buyer need not give it another opportunity within the proceedings (CA 656/99 Bar Shira). This is why the letter to the contractor and the correspondence that follows matter: they prove the opportunity was given.
In CA 656/99 Bar Shira v. Meonot U'Binyan (13 May 2003), the Supreme Court held that whether the contractor may repair the defects itself, or pay only what the repair would have cost it, depends on the circumstances. Where the contractor was given an adequate opportunity to repair before the claim was filed and did not use it, or tried and failed, the buyer need not give it another opportunity within the proceedings. In that case the contractor had neglected the repairs for years, and the Court cancelled a 35% deduction and awarded the full cost of repair by another contractor.
This is why the letter to the contractor and the correspondence that follows matter so much: years later, they are what proves the opportunity was given.
A contractor who denies the defect
A contractor who denies the very existence of the nonconformity loses the right to repair, and the buyers are entitled to the full cost of repair by other contractors. This was held in CA 11254/02 Ben Abu v. Salman, and the same applies where the contractor replied that it is not liable to the buyers at all.
The right to repair is meant for a contractor who acknowledges the defect and is willing to fix it properly. In CA 11254/02 Ben Abu Construction v. Salman (15 January 2004), the contractor installed "Rabitz" ceilings instead of the concrete ceilings in the specification and denied the nonconformity until the appeal. The Supreme Court held that once the contractor denied the very existence of the nonconformity, the buyers were not required to let it repair, and they were entitled to the full cost of repair by other contractors. In that case an addition of 30% for contractor profit and financing, and a further 8% because each buyer would repair separately, was upheld.
Similarly, in CA (Haifa District) 43959-05-16 Eden Levona v. Begelikov (14 September 2016), the buyers' lawyer asked the developer which defects it would repair and when, and the developer replied that it was not liable to them at all. The Court held that it had thereby lost the right to repair.
What an "adequate opportunity" looks like in practice
In CC (Tel Aviv Magistrates) 58418-03-11 Shemesh v. Peretz Bonei HaNegev (1 November 2012), the contractor offered to repair a ceiling defect in a way the court expert described as perpetuating the problem, and refused to explain in advance how it would repair. The Court held:
- A contractor acting in good faith should coordinate the schedule and the method of repair with the occupant in advance and in an orderly manner. Sending workers with almost no notice and no planning is not acceptable.
- The occupant may object to a cosmetic repair, or to a repair that does not follow the sale plans.
- Whether an adequate opportunity was given is examined in the period from discovery of the defect until the claim is filed. A refusal after filing does not change the picture.
This is a Magistrates' Court judgment, persuasive but not binding, yet it describes well what to ask the contractor for in writing: the list of repairs, the method and the dates.
And if it was the buyer who refused?
Where an owner refuses to let the contractor repair, compensation may be measured by what the repair would have cost the contractor itself. So if you refuse a repair the contractor proposes, say why in writing, and offer another method of repair or another date.
The reverse also applies. Where an owner refuses to let the contractor repair, compensation may be measured by what the repair would have cost the contractor itself (as explained in CA 656/99 Bar Shira, referring to CA 7799/01 Salim v. Sharviv). In CC (Tel Aviv Magistrates) 48055-03-14 Sinai v. Donitz-Kiryat HaOmanim (7 December 2017), the Court found that conditioning a flooring repair on receiving an additional parking space was unreasonable and prevented the contractor from exercising its right to repair. So if you refuse a proposed repair, say why in writing and offer another method or date.
VAT without invoices
In CA 1051/03 Ulpan Reuven v. K.M.B.K (1 August 2005), the Supreme Court held that buyers need not present invoices to receive VAT on the cost of repair, since the decision whether to actually repair or to take the money is theirs.
A waiver as a condition for repairs is void
Beyond the general rule in section 7A(a), section 7A(b) of the Sale (Apartments) Law provides that a buyer's waiver, even in writing, of rights due to a nonconformity, required as a condition for repairs, for making the apartment available, or for transferring rights to a sub-buyer, is void. In contracts signed from 7 July 2022 this also covers a waiver of compensation for late delivery.
Case law and sources
- Sale (Apartments) Law, 5733-1973: sections 4B, 7A.
- CA 656/99 Bar Shira v. Meonot U'Binyan Ltd. (13 May 2003), paras. 15-18.
- CA 11254/02 Ben Abu Construction and Development Ltd. v. Salman (15 January 2004), paras. 6, 8.
- CA 1051/03 Ulpan Reuven v. K.M.B.K Development Ltd. (1 August 2005).
- CA (Haifa District) 43959-05-16 Eden Levona v. Begelikov (14 September 2016), para. 12.
- CC (Tel Aviv Magistrates) 58418-03-11 Shemesh v. Peretz Bonei HaNegev Ltd. (1 November 2012).
- CC (Tel Aviv Magistrates) 48055-03-14 Sinai v. Donitz-Kiryat HaOmanim Ltd. (7 December 2017).
The judgments were read in full and the texts checked against the sources on 23 October 2026. This is general information and not advice on a specific matter.
About the author
Amos Ilan, Advocate, is a lawyer (Bar No. 35320) and a notary (licence 214444). The office is at 17 Tzahal Street, Nes Ziona, and handles real estate transactions, construction defects, condominium disputes and civil litigation. Alongside his legal work he has practical knowledge, not based on formal training, of engineering, appraisal and electrical and building systems, and he personally conducts the cross-examination of experts in construction defects cases.
Questions and answers
Can I claim compensation without letting the contractor repair?
Does the compensation include VAT?
Where the buyer is expected to pay another contractor for the repair, the cost of repair will usually include VAT as well, and it is advisable to claim it on that basis in the expert opinion and in the statement of claim.
I signed a completion of repairs confirmation. Have I lost my rights?
Not necessarily. The Law does not allow its provisions to be contracted out of to the buyer's detriment. The answer depends on the wording signed and the circumstances, so it is advisable to have the document reviewed.
Need a lawyer or a notary?
A short initial consultation call, to understand whether and how we can help.
