052-5927592 17 Tzahal Street, Ness Ziona Sun-Thu 09:00-19:00, Fri 09:00-12:30

How Much Compensation Is Awarded in a Construction Defects Claim: All the Components

Compensation starts with the cost of repair determined by the expert, usually the court-appointed expert. VAT and engineering supervision are added to that cost, without requiring the purchasers actually to carry out the repair. So held the Supreme Court in CA 8949/07 Ahim Ezra Building Company v. Zeev (18 November 2009). Alongside the cost of repair, compensation may be awarded for mental distress, loss of value, alternative accommodation and reimbursement of expenses.

Where the purchasers did not allow the contractor to carry out repairs, the compensation may be reduced to the cost the contractor itself would have incurred (CA 7799/01 Salim v. Sharbiv).

Worth knowing: On the other hand, where the purchasers did not allow the contractor to carry out repairs, the compensation may be reduced to the cost the contractor itself would have incurred (CA 7799/01 Salim v. Sharbiv).

What does the compensation consist of?

The compensation consists of the cost of repair according to the opinion of the court-appointed expert, VAT on the cost of repair, engineering supervision, a casual contractor premium where you carry out the repair yourself, mental distress and loss of value. Each component is examined according to what the case law has held.

ComponentWhat it includesWhat the case law has held
Cost of repairAccording to the opinion of the court-appointed expertThe appellate court is reluctant to intervene where the judgment relies on an expert appointed by consent (CA 8949/07)
VATOn the cost of repairAn integral part of the cost of repair (CA 1772/99 Zlotsin v. Diur LeOle, PD 55(4) 203)
Engineering supervisionWhere the expert determined that the repair requires supervision. A rate of 10% of the repair cost is customary in expert opinionsAwarded without being conditional on the repair being carried out (CA 8949/07)
Casual contractor premiumWhere the purchaser will carry out the repair himself, at a price higher than the contractor's priceVarious premiums have been awarded, for example 15% in CC (Krayot) 13552-06-22 Kasus v. Vradim (2024)
Mental distressNuisance, inconvenience and impaired enjoyment of the apartmentAt the court's discretion (CA 5602/03 Segal v. Shikun U'Pituach)
Loss of valueA defect that cannot be fully repaired, or an area smaller than promisedIn CA 8949/07, compensation for loss of value due to an area difference was upheld
Alternative accommodationWhere the repair requires the apartment to be vacatedAwarded where the court-appointed expert determined that the apartment could not be lived in during the repair. Where he determined that it could, it was rejected (CC (Herzliya Magistrates' Court) 44439-10-14 Boki; CC (Tel Aviv Magistrates' Court) 69533-11-17 Hanitzki)

Why are VAT and supervision paid even if the purchaser does not carry out the repair?

In CA 8949/07 the contractor argued that engineering supervision should not be awarded without making it conditional on the repair being carried out. The Supreme Court rejected the argument. It held that the practice is to award engineering supervision and VAT alongside the cost of repair, and that what the purchasers do with the money is no concern of the seller.

The court relied on the Zlotsin rule (CA 1772/99), in which it was stated that it is no concern of the contractor "whether the residents carry out repairs or not". The logic is simple: even someone who sells the apartment without repairing it will receive less for it, because the next purchaser will pay the full cost of the repair, including VAT.

However, there are judgments in which supervision was not awarded, where the defects are simple and inexpensive and it is unlikely that a supervisor would be hired for them. This was the case, for example, in CC (Jerusalem Magistrates' Court) 11393-04-18 Dahan v. Boneich Bniya (2023).

Refusing the Contractor's Repair Can Reduce Compensation in a 30-second video

Refusing the Contractor's Repair Can Reduce Compensation

The video loads from YouTube only after you click. Go to the video page and transcript

Refusing the contractor's repair can reduce your compensation. Hi, I'm Plasi! Sedki is spreading across the wall. A common mistake: refusing the contractor who comes to repair. The law gives the contractor a reasonable opportunity to repair. An unjustified refusal? Compensation may be based on the contractor's cost, and not on the cost of repair by another contractor. Notify the contractor in writing of every defect, and document every visit and every repair. Defects in your apartment? il-law.co.il

When is the compensation reduced? The contractor's right to repair

The contractor has the right to repair the defects himself, under section 4B of the Sale (Apartments) Law. In CA 472/95 Zlotsin v. Diur LeOle (1996), the Supreme Court held that the choice between repair and compensation depends on the circumstances, and that delays or failed repairs justify monetary compensation.

The other side of the coin: in CA 7799/01 Salim v. Sharbiv (2002) it was held that where the apartment owners refused to allow the contractor to carry out repairs, the compensation would be calculated according to the cost to the contractor, not according to the price they would pay on the market. It is therefore unwise to refuse a repair without taking advice. More on this in the article Repair or Compensation.

Mental distress: how much is awarded?

There is no fixed tariff. In CA 5602/03 Segal v. Shikun U'Pituach LeIsrael (2005) it was made clear that the amount of compensation for mental distress is at the court's discretion. In practice, the relevant factors are the length of time, the extent of the defects, the disruption to life in the apartment and the contractor's conduct.

Ranges of amounts published online without a source are of no help. What counts is your documentation: photographs, letters, and a description of what the defect did to the daily routine at home.

Can the owner of the construction company also be sued?

Sometimes. As a rule, the party that signed the contract is the company. In CA 8949/07 the Supreme Court upheld the personal liability of the company's owner, because it was found that he had undertaken personal obligations towards the purchasers, for example by stating that he was "personally guaranteeing". Justice Rubinstein added that this must be examined on a case-by-case basis, particularly in family-owned construction companies.

It is therefore advisable to keep every undertaking given by the company's owner, orally or in writing, and to set out in the claim the facts that establish personal liability.

A defect not worth repairing still earns compensation

Even where the court expert finds that repair is unreasonable, you can receive compensation. In CA 4218/90 Heftziba v. Lehner, the Supreme Court held that where damage is certain and only hard to quantify, compensation may be awarded by estimate.

Sometimes the court expert finds that repair is unreasonable, for example because it requires dismantling a whole room. That does not mean no compensation. In CA 4218/90 Heftziba v. Lehner (31 December 1992), the Supreme Court approved compensation even for defective tiles the expert considered not worth replacing, and held that where damage is certain and only hard to quantify, compensation may be awarded by estimate. In CA (Haifa District) 43959-05-16 Eden Levona v. Begelikov (14 September 2016), toilet and bathroom rooms more crowded than the sanitary-installation rules allow were compensated by estimate (8,000 ₪ in that case), even though repair made no sense. The developer had undertaken to build in accordance with every law and standard and could not hide behind a "design failure".

Loss of value: when is it awarded, and who proves it?

Loss of value is awarded when a defect remains in the apartment that cannot be fully repaired, or when the apartment differs from what was promised in a way that cannot be fixed. Where the defect can be fully repaired, courts tend to hold that the repair restores the apartment's value, and do not award additional compensation.

Loss of value must be proved, usually by an opinion of a real estate appraiser, and the court sometimes appoints its own appraiser. Before that, the engineering opinion needs to establish whether the defect can be repaired, because without such a finding there is no basis for an appraisal.

  • A defect not fully repaired: in CC (Herzliya Magistrates') 18563-04-22 Lemel v. V.M.L. Hatzfira Ltd. (26 August 2025) the safe room remained lower than the height promised in the specification, even after the company raised the ceiling in the rest of the apartment. The court-appointed appraiser assessed loss of value at 3.75% of the apartment's value, and the court awarded ₪46,462 based on the apartment's value close to the date possession was delivered, plus linkage differentials and interest, alongside compensation for the cost of repairing the other defects.
  • A defect that can be repaired: in CC (Nazareth Magistrates') 49258-02-17 Zeitouni v. Batzir (25 August 2022), a claim for loss of value of ₪250,000 was rejected after the court expert found that repair and monitoring would bring the house to a condition equivalent to the other houses in the neighbourhood.
  • A difference in area: in CA 8949/07 compensation for loss of value because of a difference in area was upheld.

In practice: when commissioning an engineering opinion, ask the engineer to address expressly whether each defect can be fully repaired. Only where the answer is no is it worth commissioning an appraiser as well. How to read this component in the judgment: how to read a judgment in a construction defects claim.

Buyers who already sold the apartment

Even if you sold the apartment before the proceedings ended, you are entitled to full compensation. Under CA 11254/02 Ben Abu v. Salman, the cause of action arose on the day a defective apartment was delivered to the buyer, and selling the property has no bearing on the right to compensation.

Selling the apartment before the proceedings end does not defeat compensation. In CA 11254/02 Ben Abu v. Salman (15 January 2004, para. 8), the Supreme Court held that the cause of action arose on the day a defective apartment was delivered, and that selling the property has no bearing on the right to full compensation. The argument that the apartment was sold at full price did not help the contractor either: an apartment's price is affected by many factors, and without the defect it might have sold for more. Likewise CA 1051/03 Ulpan Reuven v. K.M.B.K (1 August 2005).

The executing contractor is liable too

The executing contractor is jointly and severally liable to the buyers with the selling company, even if it signed no contract with them. This was held in Ulpan Reuven, and it matters especially where the selling company is a project company with no assets.

In many projects the company selling the apartments is not the company building them. In Ulpan Reuven the Supreme Court held that the executing contractor, which signed no contract with the buyers, is jointly and severally liable with the seller: by virtue of the duty of care of whoever builds a building, and by virtue of regulation 16.08A of the Planning and Building (Permit Application, Conditions and Fees) Regulations, 5730-1970, under which the responsibility of designers and supervisors does not exempt a main contractor from responsibility for the construction and its quality. This matters especially where the selling company is a project company with no assets.

A price quote is no substitute for an expert opinion

A contractor's quote, without measurement and a bill of quantities, is not sufficient evidence of the cost of repair. The court prefers an expert opinion, and if you seek to prove a higher cost you need an expert opinion, or repairs actually carried out and invoices.

In CC (Tel Aviv Magistrates) 48055-03-14 Sinai v. Donitz-Kiryat HaOmanim (7 December 2017), the buyers presented a contractor's quote estimating the repairs at four and a half times the court expert's figure. The Court preferred the expert, holding that the proper way to assess repair costs is an expert opinion, and that a quote without measurement and a bill of quantities is not sufficient evidence. A buyer seeking a higher figure needs an expert opinion, or repairs actually carried out and invoices.

Case law and sources

The judgments added in this update were read in full and the texts checked against the sources on 23 October 2026. This is general information and not advice on a specific matter.

About the author

Amos Ilan, Advocate, is a lawyer (Bar No. 35320) and a notary (licence 214444). The office is at 17 Tzahal Street, Nes Ziona, and handles real estate transactions, construction defects, condominium disputes and civil litigation. Alongside his legal work he has practical knowledge, not based on formal training, of engineering, appraisal and electrical and building systems, and he personally conducts the cross-examination of experts in construction defects cases.

Disclaimer. Nothing in this article constitutes legal advice or a substitute for it. Each case is examined on its own facts and documents.

Questions and answers

I received compensation. Must I use it for the repair?

As against the contractor, no. Under the Zlotsin rule, as applied in CA 8949/07, what you do with the money is no concern of the seller. Bear in mind that an unrepaired defect will affect the price of the apartment when you sell it.

My engineer assessed a high amount. Is that what I will receive?

Not necessarily. In construction defects claims, the court usually appoints its own expert, and his opinion is generally decisive. Your own expert opinion is important for filing the claim and presenting the defects. See the article on engineers' expert opinions.

Are legal fees and expert costs reimbursed?

The court awards costs and legal fees at its discretion. They usually do not cover the full expense actually incurred.

When is compensation for loss of value of the apartment awarded?

When a defect remains that cannot be fully repaired, or when the apartment differs from what was promised and this cannot be fixed. It must be proved, usually by an appraiser's opinion. Where the defect can be fully repaired, a claim for loss of value is often rejected.

Need a lawyer or a notary?

A short initial consultation call, to understand whether and how we can help.

Call WhatsApp Form